Out Now!
I’m going to start off, instead of my usual summary, by saying that I don’t get this film. I understand what it was about and I followed it, I even enjoyed it, but I don’t understand what it’s supposed to be. Seemingly a documentary it feels weirdly staged a lot of the time and events tend to play out a little too conveniently, meaning it’s too structured to feel like a documentary but not structured enough to feel like it isn’t. Conversations sometimes feel like they’ve been set up, in fact Julie (our lead) even says this at one point, accusing the director of ambushing her with a fake scenario.
In addition it seems to have a very specific audience. Nothing particularly interesting happens and there doesn’t seem to be much of a message or point to the proceedings, which helps add to the confusion of whether or not the film is fake or real. But having said all that negativity, I did actually enjoy this movie and found myself oddly compelled by the story it was telling. It’s far from a classic but I was never bored.
From what I’ve managed to gleam the film is partly staged but mostly the true life story of Julie, a professional British nanny who goes out to work for a wealthy family in the United Arab Emirates. British nannies are quite popular out there, though whether there’s a practical reason for that or if they’ve just seen Mary Poppins too many times is unclear (you kind of suspect a British nanny is a status symbol more than anything).
In addition it seems to have a very specific audience. Nothing particularly interesting happens and there doesn’t seem to be much of a message or point to the proceedings, which helps add to the confusion of whether or not the film is fake or real. But having said all that negativity, I did actually enjoy this movie and found myself oddly compelled by the story it was telling. It’s far from a classic but I was never bored.
From what I’ve managed to gleam the film is partly staged but mostly the true life story of Julie, a professional British nanny who goes out to work for a wealthy family in the United Arab Emirates. British nannies are quite popular out there, though whether there’s a practical reason for that or if they’ve just seen Mary Poppins too many times is unclear (you kind of suspect a British nanny is a status symbol more than anything).
Julie joins a large family of six children who don’t really have any kind of structure to their lives and is told by the parents to figure out how to fix this. The parents then wander off into the background and remain curiously distant from the proceedings, and though they seem like perfectly nice people and loving parents, it’s fair to say they aren’t naturals at the whole parenting thing. Anyway, with six kids to control, a new culture to get familiar with and a distant family always on her mind Julie has no choice but to dive right in.
As I said, this is an odd film. It’s doesn’t look especially compelling on the surface unless you are specifically interested in the subject matter and the design is more than a little jarring with the curiously scripted opening at the office of the agency that sends the nannies around the world and the even more bizarrely random appearance of a social media superstar during a family outing.
But as someone who knew basically nothing about what I was about to see, when I went in to this movie I found it pretty interesting. The problem may be that everything is a little out of focus. The culture clash is there, but it feels like the films not really about that. The role of a nanny and the relationship with the rest of the house staff is there, but it feels like the films not really about that. There’s some conflict with the kids, but it feels like the films not really about that. I suppose this is where the movie is clearly a documentary, after all something exciting can’t be filmed unless something exciting happens, but without a targeted focus we just sort of meander about with no real purpose and it shows at times.
As I said, this is an odd film. It’s doesn’t look especially compelling on the surface unless you are specifically interested in the subject matter and the design is more than a little jarring with the curiously scripted opening at the office of the agency that sends the nannies around the world and the even more bizarrely random appearance of a social media superstar during a family outing.
But as someone who knew basically nothing about what I was about to see, when I went in to this movie I found it pretty interesting. The problem may be that everything is a little out of focus. The culture clash is there, but it feels like the films not really about that. The role of a nanny and the relationship with the rest of the house staff is there, but it feels like the films not really about that. There’s some conflict with the kids, but it feels like the films not really about that. I suppose this is where the movie is clearly a documentary, after all something exciting can’t be filmed unless something exciting happens, but without a targeted focus we just sort of meander about with no real purpose and it shows at times.
Ultimately the film is about anything and everything in this 'Nanny Culture' so the story spreads itself a little thin perhaps. Like I say, I don’t really know what this movie is, but I enjoyed learning about the world it was set in and felt genuinely attached to Julie and the family by the end of it. There’s certainly messages and lessons on multiculturalism and class structure that can be taken from this story and it’s all very fascinating, but again, it feels like the film isn’t really about that.
Review by Kristian Mitchell-Dolby.
Tell us what you think!
Rate the film and why not write your own review in the comments?
Rate the film and why not write your own review in the comments?
RSS Feed
